Logg på
Forside Publikasjoner Skip Navigation LinksHRO and RE: A pragmatic perspective

PublikasjonStudio Apertura

 HRO and RE: A pragmatic perspective


​Forfattere: Torgeir K  Haavik, Stian Antonsen, Ragnar Rosness og Andrew Hale.

​This special issue invites to a debate to elaborate on differences and similarities between the perspectives
of High Reliability Organisation (HRO) and Resilience Engineering (RE). Such a debate may be conducted
along both essentialistic and pragmatic lines, and we suggest that the latter approach is potentially more
interesting and fruitful than the first. We use the technique of feeding off controversies and expand on
what might at first look merely like a polemic disagreement, a question of wording, namely the definition of safety as a dynamic non-event. This elaboration is used as a projector onto a canvas where a number of distinguishing themes between HRO and RE are outlined more clearly; symmetry, normativity, addressee and origin are keywords that show how HRO and RE are different, and why they cannot simply be combined into one grand theory of everything. Other concrete results from these investigations include a
review of applications of HRO and RE in health research, an elaboration of the distinction between
Safety I and Safety II, and a nuancing of how we may understand and study successful operations. We
suggest a research agenda that combines the scopes and methods of HRO and RE, possibly in combination
with other theoretical approaches. We also call for a more lively discussion on central themes of HRO and
RE, not for fighting over definitions and proving who is right, but with the aim of producing knowledge
that makes a difference regardless of theoretical stance.

Trykt versjon ikke tilgjengelig


Tlf: 91 89 77 27

Phone: (+47) 73 82 10 00

Besøksadresse: Dragvoll Allé 38 B

Visiting address: Dragvoll Allé 38 B

Postadresse: 7491 Trondheim

Postal address: 7491 Trondheim

Organisasjonsnummer: 986 243 836

VAT: 986 243 836

Copyright: NTNU Samfunnsforskning