Forfattere: Trond Kongsvik, Petter Almklov, Torgeir Haavik, Stein Haugen, Jan Erik Vinnem og Per Morten Schiefloe.
Decision making is a central component in the management of safety-critical operations. Some attempts have been made to employ Quantitative Risk Analysis as input to such decisions. Although adequate for long-term planning where the average risk is the relevant parameter, such systems tend to fall short in operational and instantaneous decisions where ‘average risk’ is of less relevance. In this paper we investigate how operational and instantaneous risk can be managed and supported.
Our analysis is based on interviews and observation studies at a major plant processing hazardous fluids and gas. We suggest a typology for decisional situations at the plant, and relate these to well-known traditions in the literature of decision-making theory. Strategic decisions in the plant fit well into the characteristics of rational choice theory, operational decisions are well described in terms of bounded rationality, and, finally, instantaneous decisions are typically taken as described by naturalistic decision making theory.
We suggest several principles for improving decision support. While many decisions today are based on a high degree of probabilistic information, we see a need to deploy more factual information to make the risk picture more relevant for both operational and instantaneous decisions. In addition, the available probabilistic information is often inaccurate; improving the probabilistic information base, through more nuanced criticality factors for example, will also be an improvement. Finally, a basic premise for improvements in the decision process, is the need to be conscious regarding what should be considered strategic, operational and instantaneous decisions.
Trykt versjon ikke tilgjengelig
Søk i alle publikasjoner fra NTNU Samfunnsforskning
Tlf: 91 89 77 27
Phone: (+47) 73 82 10 00
Besøksadresse: Dragvoll Allé 38 B
Visiting address: Dragvoll Allé 38 B
Postadresse: 7491 Trondheim
Postal address: 7491 Trondheim
Organisasjonsnummer: 986 243 836
VAT: 986 243 836
Mangfold og inkludering
Diversity and Inclusion
Senter for økonomisk forskning
Følg oss på Facebook
Ansvarlig redaktør: Roger Lian
Chief Editor: Roger Lian
Webredaktør: Vegard Smevoll
Chief Web Officer: Erik Dyrvik
Copyright: NTNU Samfunnsforskning
Om bruk av informasjonskapsler (cookies)